I thought ignoring my neighbor’s bad habit was easier than starting a feud. One comment at a neighborhood meeting changed my mind.
« Look at that face. »
My husband said it from the kitchen window like he did almost every morning.
Outside, our neighbor’s English bulldog was standing in the middle of my front lawn with the serious expression of a man completing important business.
I folded my arms. « Yes. Very cute. »
Mark grinned. « You love him. »
« I love the dog. »
A few seconds later, Bruno finished what he had come to do.
His owner, Celeste, glanced down at the pile he had left behind.
Then she looked toward her house and simply walked away.
Mark’s smile disappeared. « Again? »
« Again. »
He looked at me. « You’re going to say something eventually, right? »
I picked up the little metal shovel I had started keeping beside the garage.
« Apparently not today. »
That was pretty much how it had gone for six months.
My name is Claire. I’m 37, married to Mark, and we have two kids, Ellie, eight, and Noah, six.
We live in one of those older neighborhoods where the houses sit close together. Celeste’s place is maybe 12 feet from ours at the narrowest point.
I can hear her kettle some mornings if both kitchen windows are open.
That’s how close we are.
Which is also why I never wanted a feud.
Celeste moved in about a year and a half ago.
At first, I liked her.
She was pleasant. Not warm exactly, but polite.
She complimented my garden the first week she moved in.
« Your hydrangeas are incredible, » she said one afternoon. « What do you feed them? »
I gave her the name of the fertilizer.
She looked at the flower beds and said, « You clearly take this seriously. »
I do.
Our yard isn’t huge, but I love it.
I grow roses along the side fence. There are hydrangeas near the porch. I have herbs in raised beds out back.
I also pay a gardener twice a month during the warmer season because there are only so many hours in a weekend.
Celeste knows all of this.
She has seen me outside in July with dirt on my knees and sweat running down my back.
Which is why her behavior with Bruno bothered me so much.
Bruno, to be clear, is wonderful.
He’s a big English bulldog with a wide head, crooked teeth, and the slowest walk I’ve ever seen.
My kids adore him.
Every time he sees them, his whole back end starts wiggling.
Mark has wanted a bulldog for years.
Whenever Bruno waddles past the window, Mark says some version of, « We need one. »
We do not need one. But I have absolutely nothing against Bruno.
My problem is Celeste.
Every morning around 7:40, she brings him outside.
Not down the block. Not to the little park two streets away.
She walks him directly onto my lawn. Bruno does his business.
And she leaves it there.
The first time, I assumed she hadn’t noticed.
The second time, I assumed maybe she had forgotten a bag.
The third time, I thought, okay, this is getting rude.
By the tenth time, I knew it was deliberate.
Still, I didn’t say anything.
That probably sounds ridiculous.
But when you live 12 feet from someone, you calculate things differently.
One argument can turn into years of awkward driveway encounters and complaints over trash cans.
I kept thinking, I’ll mention it next time.
Then next time came, and I cleaned it up myself.
Sometimes Mark did.
Once, Ellie nearly stepped in it on her way to the school bus.
That was when Mark finally said, « Claire, enough. »
« I know. »
« No, you don’t. You’re still cleaning it up. »
« What do you want me to do? Knock on her door holding a bag of dog poop? »
« If necessary. »
I laughed. « I’m not starting a neighborhood war over Bruno. »
Mark gave me a look. « This isn’t about Bruno. »
He was right.
I still said nothing.
Then came the monthly neighborhood association meeting.
It’s not a formal HOA. Mostly it’s a dozen people sitting in the community room at our local library discussing parking, streetlights, and whether the summer block party should have a bounce house.
That month, Celeste showed up.
I was surprised because she usually didn’t.
Halfway through the meeting, Tom, who runs the group, asked if anyone had concerns.
Celeste raised her hand. « I do. »
I was looking at my phone, so I wasn’t paying much attention at first.
Then she said, « Some of the neighborhood children are extremely loud in the mornings. »
I looked up.
Celeste continued. « I do yoga before work, and there are days when it’s almost impossible to concentrate. »
I was shocked.
Our kids leave for school around eight.
They aren’t silent.
Sometimes Ellie and Noah chase each other down the walkway.
Sometimes their friend Ben comes over, and all three of them get loud.
But we’re talking about children laughing outside for ten minutes before school.
Tom said, « Are they doing anything inappropriate? »
« No. It’s the volume. »
Someone across the room shifted awkwardly.
Then Celeste said, « I just think certain people should learn responsibility before they have children. »
The room got very quiet.
She continued.
« If you can’t be responsible for what you’ve tamed, you shouldn’t take it on. »
And then she looked directly at me.
Not accidentally. Directly.
Two other people followed her gaze.
My face got hot.
I could feel Mark beside me stiffen.
He leaned toward me. « Say the word. »
I knew exactly what he meant.
All I had to do was stand up and say, « Funny you mention responsibility, Celeste, because your dog has been using my lawn as a toilet for six months. »
And I almost did.
But I could already imagine how it would sound.
She had spoken in a calm voice.
I would be the angry neighbor yelling about dog poop in a library meeting.
She’d shake her head and call me emotional.
So I smiled.
« Anything you’d like to say, Claire? » Tom asked carefully.
« Nope. »
Celeste looked almost disappointed.
The meeting ended 20 minutes later.
On the walk home, Mark was furious. « Why didn’t you say anything? »
« Because she wanted me to. »
« What? »
« She wanted a reaction. »
« So? »
« So I’m not giving her one in front of 12 people. »
Mark stopped walking. « Then what are you going to do? »
I thought about Celeste’s sentence.
If you can’t be responsible for what you’ve tamed, you shouldn’t take it on.
I smiled. « She’s right about one thing. »
Mark looked suspicious. « What? »
« We are responsible for what we’ve tamed. »
The next morning, I set my alarm for 7:15.
Celeste always came out around 7:40.
At 7:35, I made coffee and sat near the front window.
Mark came downstairs. « Why are you dressed? »
« I have plans. »
« What kind of plans? »
« Community improvement. »
He stared at me. « Oh no. »
At 7:42, Celeste’s front door opened.
She came outside wearing leggings and a long gray sweater with Bruno.
See more on the next page
