“I’m not asking you to leave permanently,” I said. “I’m asking you to give me some time to figure out what I want.”
“What does that mean?” he said.
“It means the bag by the door,” I said. “It means I need you to not be here for a while.”
“You can’t just.”
“I can,” I said. “The house is in my name. My name only, because your credit was a problem when we bought it and we decided to put it in mine. I’m not using that as a weapon. I’m telling you because I want you to understand the practical reality.”
He was looking at me with the expression of someone who has encountered something he had not prepared for.
“Where am I supposed to go?” he said.
“You have friends,” I said. “You just spent four days with them. You have a mother in Tempe. You have options.”
“Because you’re making me leave,” he said.
“Because I’m asking you to give me space,” I said. “There’s a difference.”
“You’re throwing me out,” he said. “Because I went on a trip.”
I looked at him.
“Brandon,” I said. “I’m asking you to leave because you told me to act like a mother when I asked you to wash the bottles. Because I have not slept more than four hours consecutively since March. Because for six months you have come home to a house where your daughters live and treated your daughters like something I was handling on your behalf. Because you needed a break from a life that I have been living without breaks.”
He was quiet.
“The trip was just the last thing,” I said. “Not the only thing.”
He was looking at his hands.
“I didn’t realize,” he said.
“I know you didn’t,” I said. “That’s part of what I need to think about.”
“If you had said something sooner,” he said.
“I said things,” I said. “Many things. The bottles. The nights. The asking. I said things and you sighed and then you went fishing.”
He put his face in his hands.
I waited.
“What do you want?” he said.
“I want to know whether you are capable of being a father the way I need a partner to be a father,” I said. “I don’t know that right now. And I need space to think about it without living in the same house while I’m thinking.”
“You’ve already decided,” he said.
“I’ve decided to take time to decide,” I said. “Those are different things.”
He looked up.
He looked at me for a long time.
Brandon was thirty-six years old and he had a good face that I had loved for eight years and that I looked at now with the particular clarity of someone who has been thinking clearly for four days without interruption, and what I saw in his face was not a bad man.
I want to be accurate about this because accuracy is not something I am willing to give up even when it would be easier to give it up. He was not a bad man. He was a man who had not risen to what was required and who had let himself not rise because I had absorbed the gap between what was required and what he offered, and the absorbing had made the not-rising invisible to him for six months.
The sentence had been cruel. That was true and I was not willing to soften it.
But he was not a man who had said it from cruelty exactly. He had said it from a smallness of understanding, from a failure to see me as separate from the role he had placed me in, from a failure to understand what the words cost in the context of everything that had preceded them.
That failure was the thing I needed to know whether he could address.
“I need you to go,” I said. “And I need you to think about what kind of father you want to be. Not as an abstraction. Specifically. In terms of nights and mornings and bottles and what happens when I am at the end of what I can manage.”
He stood up.
He picked up the bag.
He stood in the kitchen for a moment.
“The girls,” he said.
“I’m not keeping you from them,” I said. “That was never part of this. I need you to not live here while I figure out what I want. We can establish a schedule for you to see them.”
He nodded.
He looked like he wanted to say something else.
He went to the nursery first. I stood in the kitchen and I heard him move through the house toward the girls’ room, and I heard him open the door quietly, the way you open a door when babies are sleeping, and I heard him in there for a few minutes, just being there, and I thought about Clara and Nora and what they would know about this period when they were old enough to know things, and I hoped they would know only that both of their parents had tried to figure out how to do right by them.
He came back through the living room.
He stopped at the door.
“I don’t want to lose this,” he said.
“I know,” I said.
“What do I do?” he said.
“Figure out what you’re willing to do,” I said. “Not for me. For them. And then we talk.”
He left.
I stood in the clean kitchen for a moment.
Then my mother came out of the nursery.
She had heard everything, or most of it, which I had known she would hear and had decided was all right.
She looked at me.
“Tea?” she said.
“Yes,” I said.
She made tea and we sat at the kitchen table and the afternoon light came through the windows and Clara made a sound in the nursery that might have been waking or might have been settling and then was quiet again.
“You did that very well,” my mother said.
“I don’t know if I did it well,” I said. “I did it honestly.”
“Which is how it should be done,” she said.
“I might have just blown up my marriage,” I said.
“You might have,” she said. “Or you might have made the first honest conversation about it possible.”
She put her hands around her tea.
“When your father and I were in the hard years,” she said. “I don’t know if I ever told you this. When you were about three and your brother was a baby and your father was working the double shifts. I spent a week not speaking to him.”
“I didn’t know that,” I said.
“A full week,” she said. “He thought I was just tired. I was more than tired. I was finished in a way that I didn’t have words for.” She looked at her tea. “He noticed the third day. He asked what he was missing. And I told him.”
“What happened?” I said.
“He cried,” she said. “Which I had never seen him do. And then he made dinner every night for two months without being asked.”
“And you stayed,” I said.
“We stayed,” she said. “Because what I needed was for him to see it. And once he saw it, he couldn’t un-see it.”
“What if Brandon can’t un-see it?” I said.
“Then you’ll have information you need,” she said. “And you’ll make the decision that information requires.”
We drank the tea.
The girls stayed asleep until five, which was a mercy.
Brandon called that evening from his friend Derek’s house, where he was staying. He asked if he could come over the following Saturday to see the girls. I said yes.
He came on Saturday.
He brought nothing, no offering, no compensatory gesture, which I noted as the right instinct even if it might have been accidental. He came to see his daughters and he held them both and he was more present in that hour than he had been in many of the evenings of the preceding six months, the quality of his attention different, directed rather than peripheral.
Before he left he asked if we could talk.
“Not today,” I said.
“When?” he said.
“I’ll tell you when,” I said.
He nodded.
He was there the following Saturday, and the one after that.
He started a schedule with me, a text each week proposing specific times, specific days, what he could offer, which was not every day but was more than it had been, and the offering had the quality of something he had thought about rather than something he was performing.
Three weeks after he left, he called me at eleven in the evening.
“I’ve been talking to someone,” he said. “A therapist. To understand what happened.”
“Okay,” I said.
“I’m not saying this to get you to let me come home,” he said. “I’m saying it because I thought you should know.”
“I appreciate that,” I said.
“He said some things I didn’t want to hear,” he said.
“Good,” I said.
There was a pause.
“You did all of that while I took fishing trips,” he said.
“Yes,” I said.
“The three years,” he said. “The IVF. After all of that, I told you to act like a mother.”
“Yes,” I said.
He was quiet.
“I keep thinking about what that must have felt like,” he said.
“You should keep thinking about it,” I said.
“I am,” he said. “I will.”
I sat on the couch in the quiet house after the girls had gone to sleep and I held the phone and I thought about the three years and what they had built and what had been built on top of them and whether the thing underneath was worth building back up to.
I did not know yet.
What I knew was what the four days had taught me, which was that I was more capable than I had been told, capable enough to do the thing alone when I had to, which meant that any arrangement I entered now would be chosen rather than required.
I would not stay from fear.
If I stayed, it would be because there was something real to stay for.
The girls were nine months old when Brandon moved back in.
Not because I had decided everything was resolved but because what I had watched for six weeks was a man learning to look at something he had looked away from, and because the therapist he was seeing had given him a framework for understanding what had happened that was not self-serving, which I knew because I had called the therapist myself and asked.
The therapist had said: “He’s doing the work. I can’t promise outcomes. I can tell you he’s not faking the discomfort.”
I believed that was sufficient to try.
The night he moved back in, I made dinner and we ate together while the girls were in the bouncer seats in the kitchen, Clara gnawing on a teething ring and Nora making the specific sound she made when she was interested in what was happening around her.
Brandon washed the bottles after dinner.
He did not say anything about it.
I did not say anything about it.
He just washed them.
Then he picked up Nora, who had been fussing, and carried her to the living room and walked her in the specific pattern that soothed her, which he had learned over the preceding weeks of Saturday visits, which was around the couch twice and then to the window to look outside.
I watched him do this and I thought about what my mother had said about my father making dinner every night for two months without being asked.
Not proof. Not resolution.
A beginning.
Clara reached up from her seat and grabbed at the air with her small fists, which was what she did when she wanted to be held, and I picked her up and she went immediately solid and warm against my chest and grabbed my shirt in both hands the way she always did, the specific grip of someone who has identified something dependable and is not letting go.
I stood in my kitchen holding my daughter and I thought about the three years and the two miscarriages and the bathroom at seven in the morning and the sentence that Brandon had said and the four days after, and I thought about what I had learned in those four days, which was that I was capable of doing this, that I had been capable all along, and that the choice to do it with someone rather than without someone was a choice I made with full information about my own capability.
That mattered.
The mattering of it was not small.
Brandon came back into the kitchen with Nora, who had settled, and we stood in the kitchen and the girls looked at each other across the space between us in the way they had been looking at each other since March, with the specific recognition of people who have always known each other, which they had, which was the strangest and most extraordinary thing about them.
“I’ll take the one o’clock feeding,” Brandon said.
“Which one?” I said.
“Whoever wakes up,” he said.
I looked at him.
“You don’t have to,” I said.
“I know I don’t have to,” he said. “I want to.”
There is a difference between those two things.
I had said that to him and he had heard it.
“Okay,” I said.
He took the one o’clock feeding.
I woke at one-fifteen to silence and understood what the silence meant, and I lay in the dark and I let myself be still for a moment, and outside the window the Arizona night was doing what it did, clear and warm and full of the specific quiet of a neighborhood where everyone was asleep.
I thought about Clara and Nora.
I thought about the three years.
I thought about the four days.
I thought about what you become when you have to discover what you are capable of on your own, and whether that discovering is a thing that can be shared with someone after you have done it, whether it can be the foundation of something different from what came before.
I thought it could be.
Not easily. Not without continued work and continued watching and continued honest conversations of the kind that Brandon and I had not been good at and were learning.
But possible.
Clara made a sound down the hall.
I heard Brandon’s voice, low and settling, the specific tone of a parent with a wakeful baby at one in the morning, and Clara was quiet.
I closed my eyes.
I slept.
Thanks for reading
See more on the next page
