My boyfriend disappeared the same night I told him I was pregnant. But when Grandfather finally looked into our baby’s eyes, he reacted with such distress that for the first time I wondered if Caleb’s disappearance might never have been accidental.
The hospital grew smaller and smaller in the rearview mirror as Nora slept beside me. After thirteen long days in the neonatal intensive care unit, I was finally able to take my daughter home.
I thought the hardest part was now behind us.
After almost two weeks spent navigating hospital corridors, undergoing examinations, whispering to nurses, and waiting for hours by Nora’s bed, the mere thought of finally being able to take her home felt surreal. For the first time, there would be no monitors beside her, no regular checkups, and no doors constantly being crossed. Just Nora and me.
My daughter had Caleb’s dark curls, his dimple in his chin, and most of all, his eyes.
One eye was bright blue.
The other one was so dark that it almost looked black.
This unusual combination caught the attention of everyone who looked at it.
My parents had died when I was ten years old, so I hardly knew what traits had appeared in our family earlier.
“Someone else in the family must have eyes like that too,” the nurse had said at the discharge.
“Your father,” I had replied quietly.
Just saying those two words hurt.
I hadn’t spoken Caleb’s name out loud for months.
He disappeared the same night I told him about the pregnancy.
No message.
No farewell letter.
No calls were answered.
Nothing.
The worst part wasn’t even just his disappearance. It was the fact that there had been no warning beforehand.
When I showed him the positive pregnancy test, Caleb stared at it silently for several seconds. Then he looked at me.
« Are you all right? »
« I don’t know it. »
He took my hand.
« Then we’ll find out together. »
I had looked at him and tried to see something in his face that told me what was going on inside him.
« Aren’t you afraid? »
« I am terrified. »
I laughed despite my tears.
It wasn’t a perfect reaction. But it was honest. And most importantly, it didn’t feel like the reaction of a man who was already planning to disappear from my life.
Before Caleb left that evening, he had kissed me on the forehead.
He had said he would call the next morning.
He didn’t.
Around noon, my messages were still unread.
In the evening, I was immediately redirected to his mailbox.
The following morning, I could no longer bear the uncertainty and drove to his apartment.
There I noticed something that immediately shattered my initial hope.
Half of his wardrobe was empty.
At that moment I realized that it couldn’t have just been panic.
Caleb hadn’t suddenly become overwhelmed and simply forgotten to get in touch.
He had packed some things.
He had left his apartment.
He had gone somewhere.
And he had done it deliberately.
Nevertheless, I waited.
I waited for a phone call, a message, some kind of explanation. Days turned into weeks. Weeks turned into months.
At some point, around my fifth month of pregnancy, I inwardly stopped assuming every unknown phone call was for Caleb.
At that time, Grandfather Walter was in his garage sanding the crib he was preparing for Nora.
He told me we would manage.
Just the three of us.
Grandfather, Nora and I.
My parents died when I was ten, and since then my grandfather had raised me. He was more than just my grandfather to me. He was the person who remained when almost everything else had suddenly disappeared.
The few things I still owned from my mother had been lying in a cedar wood box at the very back of my wardrobe for years.
Old photographs.
Letters.
A few small mementos.
I never had the courage to look at everything thoroughly.
Perhaps I was afraid of meeting a version of my mother that had nothing to do with my fragmented childhood memories.
During my pregnancy, my grandfather was by my side at every important moment.
He drove me to every preventative care appointment.
And when the woman said during the ultrasound that it was a girl, he started to cry.
That’s why, on that afternoon as I drove home with Nora, I thought that something good was finally beginning.
Shortly after four o’clock I turned onto Grandfather’s gravel driveway.
He was already sitting on the porch.
He had done this almost every afternoon for the past two weeks, as if his mere presence there could ensure that we would eventually return.
When he saw my car, he jumped up so quickly that his coffee cup fell off the armrest of the rocking chair.
It broke on the wooden planks of the veranda.
« There are my girls! » he exclaimed.
Then he came down the steps, two at a time, surprisingly fast for a seventy-three-year-old man.
I opened the car door and carefully lifted Nora out of her seat.
Grandfather opened his arms as if he had held them outstretched since the day we arrived at the hospital.
“Say hello to your great-grandfather,” I whispered, gently placing Nora in the crook of his arm.
I expected him to cry.
What I hadn’t expected was fear.
For a moment, his entire facial expression softened.
He looked at Nora as if there were nothing more precious in the world.
Then he turned her slightly towards the afternoon light.
His gaze drifted to her eyes.
From one bright blue eye to the other, almost black one.
Then he looked at her chin.
The small dimple.
The color drained from his face.
« Grandfather? »
His hands began to tremble.
He continued to keep Nora safe, but I could see how much something was shaking him.
« Emily. Who is her father? »
I laughed nervously.
« You know his name. Caleb. »
Whatever Grandfather had feared, this name confirmed it.
He slowly lowered himself into the wicker chair.
« Caleb. And his father? »
“William. Grandfather, you frighten me.”
He pressed his lips to Nora’s forehead and closed his eyes.
« No, my darling. God, no. »
For a moment I felt as if the porch was going to tip over beneath my feet.
A terrible thought flashed through my mind.
« Grandfather. Please. Are you telling me that Caleb and I… »
I couldn’t finish the sentence.
His head immediately jerked up.
“No, my darling. God, no. You are not related. Not blood relatives.”
The relief hit me so hard that I almost laughed.
But if that wasn’t the reason for his reaction, only one other question remained.
« Then what? »
Grandfather looked again at Nora’s differently colored eyes.
His own eyes filled with tears.
« I promised your mother I would never tell you about it. Sarah made me swear an oath years before the accident. »
« Swear what? »
« That you would grow up without this family in your life. »
He looked away.
« And after she died, I was glad to be able to keep that promise. After everything William had done to her, I didn’t want anyone from that family near you. »
I slowly sat down on the top step of the veranda and gripped the railing.
« What did William do? »
Grandfather took a deep breath.
« Your mother was his nanny. »
I stared at him.
« From whom? »
« Caleb out. »
The answer reached me with a delay.
Grandfather continued.
« When Caleb was seven years old, your mother worked for his family. She lived in this house. And you lived there too, Emily. You were four or five years old. »
Something stirred deep within my memory.
No clear memory.
More like pictures.
Colors.
Places that suddenly no longer felt like fantasy.
« A big house, » I whispered. « There was a garden. And a red bicycle. »
Grandfather nodded.
“Yes.”
I closed my eyes.
« And a boy. »
My breath caught in my throat.
« There was a boy who always ran with me. »
Grandfather looked at me for a long time.
« That was Caleb. »
Suddenly, things that had seemed strange or random during our relationship no longer felt random.
I put my hand over my mouth.
Nora moved quietly against her grandfather’s shoulder.
Almost two years.
Almost two years had passed since Caleb had stood in the aisle of a bookstore during a reading, turned to me, and spoken my name as if he already knew it.
After that came coffee, long car journeys and quiet evenings in his apartment.
I thought we had met by chance.
Apparently, even our first meeting wasn’t truly accidental.
Grandfather continued speaking.
« After Caleb’s mother died, William began stalking your mother. Sarah rejected him. He then fired her and made sure that no decent family in the area would hire her. »
Another image flickered in my mind.
« I remember screaming, » I said.
A door.
My mother.
A man.
His voice.
« A man shouted at Mom in a doorway. »
“That was William,” said Grandfather. “I confronted him once. Caleb was there. He was holding onto the banister and watching us.”
Tears welled up in my eyes.
« I forgot all of that. »
It felt almost like a betrayal of my own memory.
« I have forgotten everything. »
“Your mother put you in the car that same week,” Grandfather said. “After that, we never spoke about that family again in this house.”
« But Caleb is not William. »
Grandfather’s expression hardened.
« He is William’s son. »
« That doesn’t automatically make him his father. »
« After what his father had done to your mother, I didn’t want to find out if Caleb was different. »
I looked at my daughter.
Grandfather’s voice became quieter again.
« And then he disappeared the moment you told him about the baby. Emily, my darling, I thought that proved me right. »
I looked at Nora.
His explanation made sense.
And yet something was missing.
“If Caleb was simply cruel,” I said slowly, “why did he stay for two years?”
Grandfather had no answer to that.
I stood up carefully.
My knees still ached from the many hours I had spent sitting next to an incubator in recent weeks.
« I have to find out for myself. »
„Emily …“
« Not through you. Not through what William did to my mother. I need to know what Caleb actually did to me. »
Grandfather closed his eyes.
I took Nora back into my arms.
Even on my way to my car, I knew where I would begin.
In my mother’s past.
My mother’s cedar wood box
That night, after Nora had fallen asleep, I pulled the old cedar wood box out of my wardrobe.
If Grandfather had hidden an entire family from me, I needed to know what else had been hidden.
I sat down on the floor and opened the lid.
The familiar smell of wood wafted towards me.
I was looking for something that would prove to me that Grandfather had been wrong about Caleb.
Instead, I found evidence that Caleb had also hidden things from me.
A photograph lay beneath several old scarves.
I was about four years old at the time and was sitting on a red bicycle.
A dark-haired boy was standing next to me.
A black eye.
An almost black one.
Caleb.
I didn’t have to look at the picture twice.
Now that I had looked at Nora every day, I recognized those eyes immediately.
There was a bundle of letters underneath the photo.
The oldest one was written in careful childlike handwriting.
« Dear Sarah, where did the little girl go? Did she take her bicycle? Please write back. Caleb. »
My throat tightened.
He hadn’t forgotten me.
Not even back then.
I opened the next letter.
Then the next one.
The handwriting changed slightly with each letter.
The clumsy letters of a child became the faster lines of a teenager and finally the handwriting of a young man.
A letter from his youth contained folded banknotes.
« I saved this from my pocket money. Please use it for her. Please tell me she’s okay. »
I held the letter in my hands for a long time.
A later letter was written in a messier, older handwriting.
« Grandfather says he’ll leave me something when I’m old enough. Dad says I’ll never get any of it without him. Maybe one day I can finally help you myself. »
Caleb had known who I was.
He had apparently spent years trying to find out how I was doing.
On the back of the last letter, my mother had written five words in her familiar slanted handwriting:
« He is not like his father. »
I stared at the sentence.
My mother had trusted Caleb long before I was old enough to consciously remember him.
Now I had to find out if I had been foolish to place the same trust in him later.
Then another memory came back.
Months before I knew I was pregnant, Caleb and I had sat on his sofa.
Almost casually, he asked me if I had owned a red bicycle as a child.
I laughed and said, yes, my mother bought it secondhand.
At that moment, he had looked up at the ceiling and smiled.
I didn’t think anything of it.
Now I understand that expression.
It was the smile of a person who had finally received the answer to a question he had been carrying around with him for twenty years.
Even our meeting in the bookstore suddenly appeared in a completely different light.
Caleb had come in during the question-and-answer session.
He hadn’t found me by chance.
And every time I had spoken about the wealthy family for whom my mother had previously worked, he had listened silently.
I had told him how she lost everything afterwards.
How she carried shame about that time with her until her death.
Caleb knew exactly who I was talking about.
And he had remained silent.
See more on the next page
